Mar 31, 2018· 1. God can't make the stone - it is logically impossible to make such a stone 2. God can make the stone, but it is impossible to lift it since an omnipotent being has made the stone unliftable. But since God's omnipotence only means that he must be able to do what is logically possible, not lifting a stone does not disqualify him from ...
Oct 08, 2020· God cannot win in a fist fight with himself, make a square circle, create a triangle whose angles do not add up to 180 degrees, create a prison so secure that he can't escape from it or create …
Why does Mavrodes say that the following question contains a logical contradiction: "If God is all powerful, can he create a stone that he cannot lift?" Because the very idea of a stone too heavy for a omnipotent being to lift contradicts the meaning of omnipotence.
Therefore, God can create a rock of tremendous size, but, since He is all-powerful, He will always be able to lift it. The ability to fail is not a part of omnipotence. The Bible makes it clear that God is able to do anything He wants to, and that nothing He wants to do is too difficult for Him to accomplish. 4 This is the true meaning of ...
Aug 03, 2016· If we say yes, then we concede that there is something God can't do because God would then create a rock which He couldn't lift. The thing God couldn't do would be to lift the rock. On the other hand, if we say no, then we also concede that there's something God cannot do. Namely, create a rock which He can't lift.
Answer: Prabhupada gave one simple answer to this. He will create a stone he can't lift and then he will lift it. that is the meaning of God. God can do anything. At one level he can create a thing which he cannot lift and at next level he can expand his energy and lift it. That is one level of explanation.
It works like this. God is supposed to be omnipotent. If He is omnipotent, then He can create a rock so big that He can't pick it up. If He cannot make a rock like this, then He is not omnipotent. If He can make a rock so big that He can't pick it up, then He isn't omnipotent either. Either way demonstrates that God cannot do something.
Q: "Can god make a rock so heavy that he couldn't lift it?" …Let's find out! God, being omnipotent, space-savvy and ubiquitous, would have himself exist simultaneously on Plane (A) and Plane (B). After fashioning a rock with a weight sufficient to...
Nov 01, 2017· If you say He can lift any stone, then once again He's not able to do a certain task, which is to create a stone too heavy for him to lift." The Christian guy was dumbstruck and the atheist acclaimed," Your God is just a flying spaghetti monster, who exists only in imagination but cannot stand against scrutiny!!!"
Dec 18, 2019· It's the omnipotence paradox. The paradox posits that as a omnipotent creature can create anything, it should be able to create something it can't lift. As far as the laws of logic go however, No, God can't create a rock he can't lift - yet that d...
Yes, it contains the equivocation of the concept "God". Without knowing the properties of this being, and without answering the question if and how this being exists, if and how this being interacts with reality, the question is asking about ficti...
Mar 27, 2000· A poor excuse for a paradox.It just falls in love with its ability to say "P and not P". Of course omnipotence does not include the ability to do the logically impossible (although the physically impossible is possible for the omnipotent). People who believe that God is omnipotent (and understand the issues) don't believe that God can create a stone so heavy even he can't lift it, any more ...
He can create an unliftable rock, but it will only be unliftable to the creation, not the Creator God; He still lift that unliftable rock though, because nothing can limit His ability. This may seem like like a paradox, which according to a dictionary definition means "a seemingly absurd or contradictory statement or proposition which when ...
Aug 02, 2011· And it's that same love that allows the rock that God cannot lift to be moved. For you see Jesus cannot move that rock, for he is the one separated. The Father cannot move the rock for he is the one that has judged sin. It is the Spirit that was able to step into that gap and restore the relationship.
Nov 08, 2009· "Can God create a stone and pull it in one direction so hard that He can not pull it in the other direction?" At this point it is no longer about God's ability, but His will. So when we interpret the question where a stone means a normal stone, heavy means heavy etc. it does not make any sense.
Creating a rock so heavy He could not lift it is one of a few things an all-powerful God cannot do since it would violate His very nature and definition as God. God's omnipotence does not mean He can contradict Himself or perform logical impossibilities. For example, God could not create something that existed before or after Him because He is ...
The "God of contradiction could create a stone that he can't lift, yet as all of life is in an instant, he would (at what would appear to us to be a different time) lift it as well. We can thus not rule out an omnipotent being in timelessness where omnipotence is conceivable.
If we say that God can create such a stone, then it seems that there might be such a stone. And if there might be a stone too heavy for Him to lift, then He is evidently not omnipotent. But if we deny that God can create such a stone, we seem to have given up his omnipotence already. Both answers lead us to the same conclusion.'
An all powerful God can do or make anything, but it's meaningless to say that he can do or make a nothing. A logically contradictory state of affairs is not a thing at all, but NOTHING. The point is, 'a rock too heavy for God to lift' is really 'a rock too heavy for a being who can lift anything', so it …
Apr 23, 2007· Yes, god creates stones he cannot lift, but in the end, it is not god that lifts the stone, but your belief that god can lift the stone. the stone is only a physical blockade between your faith in gods power. "GOD" is only a mental creation of power, not a physical person or power. If you bevlieve in god, an believe the stone can move, it will.
An atheist asked 'Can God create a stone, which He cannot lift?' Swami replied: Your question indicates that God is defined as omnipotent.In fact, we define God so. For example – Assume that ...
Aug 27, 2011· - Can God Make a Stone So Heavy He Can't Lift It? Dr. William Lane Craig answers a question about God's attribute. In this case, H...
"If God is all powerful, can s/he create a stone so heavy s/he cannot lift it?" Thomas Aquinas and Rene Descartes, among others, would no doubt be relieved to know that the English Supreme Court has now resolved the matter (in Rock Advertising v MWB Business Exchange Centres). At least, that is no doubt what Lord Sumption would like us to ...
Nov 17, 2020· The omnipotence paradox provides arguments to dispute both the existence of an omnipotent god as well as the existence of omnipotence itself. The paradox provides examples of two outcomes, both of which leave god with limited powers, and therefore not omnipotent. The most popular example is the paradox of the stone. The paradox of the…
